Misc. cases I

[Lady Cop]

Orlando Sentinel
October 6, 2011
Amanda Brumfield, the estranged daughter of actor Billy Bob Thornton, was sentenced to 20 years in prison Thursday for aggravated manslaughter in the 2008 death her goddaughter, who died while in her care.

Brumfield was convicted on a charge of aggravated manslaughter of a child in May.

She had initially faced a murder charge for the death of 1-year-old Olivia Madison Garcia, during an overnight stay at her Ocoee home in October 2008. But Brumfield was found not-guilty of first-degree murder and aggravated child-abuse.

Brumfield had said she frequently cared for Olivia, her friend Heather Murphy's daughter, at her home and has maintained the girl was trying to climb out of a playpen and fell a short distance, hitting her head. The defense suggested the fall may have aggravated a previous injury.

The prosecution argued it was impossible that a fall from that height caused a 3 1/2-inch fracture on the back of the girl's skull and the bleeding and swelling found in her brain.

Brumfield, shackled at the waist and wearing a dark blue jail jumpsuit, sat at the defense table with her lawyers as she awaited her fate Thursday.

Emotions ran high as loved ones of both women, once the closest of friends, sat in Courtroom 10D of the Orange County Courthouse.

Murphy delivered an emotionally wrenching statement on the loss of her child, whom she called Liv.

"I can't believe you're gone," she said. "All I want to do is take you trick-or-treating, and to dress you up as Tinkerbell … Mommy is so incomplete without you."

The toddler with the wild hair and toothy smile loved mandarin oranges, her mom said, and enjoyed playing with doorstops so much that she broke all of them in the family's home

Olivia's older sister Isabella is still struggling with the loss as well, she said. The girl still asks when her sister is coming home, Murphy said, and on her birthday, "she wanted to tie an ice cream cone to a balloon so Liv would have something to snack on in heaven."

Sept. 30 would have been Olivia's 4^th birthday, Murphy said, and the sentencing fell three years to the day after the little girl's funeral.

When the judge asked Brumfield if she had anything to say, she managed a single sentence before breaking down. "I miss Olivia just as much as anybody does," she said.

Brumfield's family and friends, many of whom wore white shirts in the courtroom in a show of support, were visibly angered and distraught by the sentence.

Brumfield has two children of her own as well as a stepchild. Olivia was a frequent presence in her home, and treated as part of the family, the defense said.

The defense presented testimony from Brumfield's pastor and a close friend, both of whom praised her as a caring mother who opened her home to friends in need and would never deliberately harm a child.

Christina Stewart, who described herself as Brumfield's best friend, read a letter from Brumfield to the court. "Olivia brought joy to our family from the moment she was born," she wrote. "Olivia always was, is and will be my little girl."

The defense had hoped that Judge Reginald Whitehead would hand down a more lenient sentence. He acknowledged the sadness of the situation for all involved before issuing the sentence.

Whitehead credited Brumfield for 165 days served, and also ordered payment of investigative and prosecution costs totaling about $10,000.

Outside the courthouse, Murphy said the sentence was "more than I expected … I feel justice has been served."

However, she said, no sentence, however severe or lenient, will help ease the pain of the loss of her daughter.